YouMass
  Current User:
  MASTEP GUEST
 
Stormwater Technologies Clearinghouse
Project Information Stormwater Library The Database External Links Contact
Log On |Registration | Forgot Password | Home Page

Displayed: All Records
BMP Performance Comparison Table
(table contains pollution removal ratings for all proprietary BMPs rated 1 or 2)

Important! MASTEP status rating numbers do not equate directly to BMP performance. They rate the availability of credible performance data for a technology. A #1 rating does not necessarily mean a BMP performs better than one rated #2 or #3; it means you can have more confidence in performance evaluation studies of that product.  Please read the data review explanation before making any decisions based on the information provided in this database.

#
Rated By
1
O/G, Floatables, SSC, DS
Drop In
Enviropod :: BMP Type: Catch Basin Insert (Pretreatment Technology). Pollutants Addressed: Debris- sinking; Suspended sediment concentration; Oil and grease; Debris - floatables ] Product of Contech Stormwater Solutions, Inc.
2
SSC
VF4r
VortFilter :: BMP Type: Inorganic Filter (Filtration - Media filter). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids; Total solids; Oil and grease; Debris - floatables; Debris- sinking; Zinc; Copper; Lead; Iron; Chromium; Mercury; Cadmium; Hydrocarbons; Organic contaminants; Salt; Fecal coliform; E. coli; Enterococcus; Nitrate-nitrite; Total nitrogen; Total Phosphorus; Temperature ] Product of Vortechnics Inc.
3
TSS, TP, O/G, Zn, Cu
BMP01
Clearwater Solutions BMP01 :: BMP Type: Catch Basin Insert (Pretreatment Technology). Pollutants Addressed: Debris- sinking; Total suspended solids; Oil and grease; Debris - floatables; Zinc; Copper; Lead; Total Phosphorus ] Product of Clearwater Solutions
4
TSS, TPH
n/a
Hydro-Kleen™ Filtration System :: BMP Type: Catch Basin Insert (Pretreatment Technology). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Hydrocarbons ] Product of Hydro Compliance Management Inc.
5
TSS
Several
Cultec Contactor and Cultec Recharger :: BMP Type: Chamber - Plastic (Infiltration). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids ] Product of Cultec
6
TSS, O/G, SSC
FGP-24F
FloGard+Plus :: BMP Type: Catch Basin Insert (Pretreatment Technology). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids; Oil and grease; Total Phosphorus ] Product of Kristar Enterprises, Inc.
7
Floatables
Floating
Netting Trash Trap :: BMP Type: Advance inlet structure (Pretreatment Technology). Pollutants Addressed: Debris - floatables ] Product of Fresh Creek Technologies Inc.
8
Floatables, TS, DS
4 cartridge 6 x 12 vault
StormScreen :: BMP Type: Synthetic Filter (Filtration - Media filter). Pollutants Addressed: Debris - floatables; Debris- sinking; Total suspended solids; Total solids ] Product of Contech Stormwater Solutions, Inc.
9
TSS, O/G, Zn, TPH
4105-L
Hydrocartridge :: BMP Type: Catch Basin Insert (Pretreatment Technology). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Oil and grease; Zinc; Hydrocarbons ] Product of Advanced Aquatic Products
10
TSS, O/G, TPH
Drop Inlet
DrainPac :: BMP Type: Catch Basin Insert (Pretreatment Technology). Pollutants Addressed: Oil and grease; Hydrocarbons; Total suspended solids ] Product of United Stormwater Inc.
11
TSS, O/G
Module II
Hancor Storm Water Quality Unit :: BMP Type: Oil/sediment separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Debris - floatables; Hydrocarbons; Total suspended solids; Oil and grease ] Product of Hancor Inc.
12
TS
GSRD
Storm Flo Screen :: BMP Type: Screen separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Total solids ] Product of Roscoe Moss Company
13
TSS
4-FT
Downstream Defender :: BMP Type: Swirl or vortex separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Oil and grease; Debris - floatables; Total suspended solids; Total solids ] Product of Hydro International
14
EC, Ent
Models DI and CO
Ultra-Urban® Filter with Smart Sponge Plus 4 Antimicrobial :: BMP Type: Catch Basin Insert (Pretreatment Technology). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Oil and grease; Debris - floatables; E. coli; Enterococcus ] Product of Abtech Industries
15
TSS, SSC
StormFilter
Stormwater Management StormFilter :: BMP Type: Inorganic Filter (Filtration - Media filter). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids; Zinc; Copper; Lead; Cadmium; Total Keldhal Nitrogen; Total Phosphorus; Biochemical oxygen demand ] Product of Contech Stormwater Solutions, Inc.
16
TSS, SSC
TK18
Terre Kleen :: BMP Type: Hydrodynamic device - other (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids; Oil and grease ] Product of Terre Hill Concrete Products
17
TSS, TKN, TP, SSC, TDS
StarFilter disks + Arkal Media Filters AGF
Arkal Pressurized Stormwater Filtration System :: BMP Type: Synthetic Filter (Filtration - Media filter). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Zinc; Total Phosphorus; Total Keldhal Nitrogen; Total dissolved solids; Suspended sediment concentration ] Product of Arkal Filtration Systems
18
TSS, TKN, TP, Pb
Not specified
StormTreat System (TM), Inc. :: BMP Type: Oil/sediment separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Total Phosphorus; Total suspended solids; Zinc; Lead; Chromium; Fecal coliform; Total Keldhal Nitrogen ] Product of StormTreat Systems
19
TSS, SSC
STC 1200
Stormceptor :: BMP Type: Oil/sediment separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration; Oil and grease; Zinc; Copper; Lead; Iron; Chromium; Mercury; Cadmium; Total suspended solids; Ammonium; Hydrocarbons; Total Keldhal Nitrogen; Total Phosphorus ] Product of Stormceptor
20
TSS, TP, NH4+, SSC, TDS
7000 and 1000 and 2000
Vortechs System :: BMP Type: Swirl or vortex separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Total dissolved solids; Oil and grease; Debris- sinking; Debris - floatables; Total solids; Chromium; Mercury; Hydrocarbons; Organic contaminants; E. coli; Enterococcus; Zinc; Copper; Lead; Iron; Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids; Salt; Fecal coliform; Cadmium; Ammonium; Total nitrogen; Total Phosphorus ] Product of Contech Stormwater Solutions, Inc.
21
SSC
VS40
VortSentry :: BMP Type: Swirl or vortex separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Oil and grease; Zinc; Iron; Cadmium; Organic contaminants; E. coli; Total Phosphorus; Temperature; Copper; Lead; Chromium; Mercury; Ammonium; Hydrocarbons; Salt; Fecal coliform; Enterococcus; Total nitrogen; Debris - floatables; Debris- sinking; Total suspended solids; Total solids; Suspended sediment concentration ] Product of Contech Stormwater Solutions, Inc.
22
TSS, TP, Zn, TPH
AG-18
Agua-Guardian Catch Basin Insert :: BMP Type: Catch Basin Insert (Pretreatment Technology). Pollutants Addressed: Hydrocarbons; Total Phosphorus; Total suspended solids; Zinc ] Product of AquaShield
23
SSC
OSR 250
Stormceptor OSR :: BMP Type: Oil/sediment separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids ] Product of Imbrium Systems Corporation
24
TSS
4-foot diameter
First Defense :: BMP Type: Swirl or vortex separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids ] Product of Hydro International
25
TSS
DVS (Dual Vortex Separator)
FloGard Dual Vortex Hydrodynamic Separator :: BMP Type: Hydrodynamic device - other (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Oil and grease; Hydrocarbons; Debris - floatables; Debris- sinking ] Product of Kristar Enterprises, Inc.
26
Floatables, DS
FG-TDG42
FloGard Trash & Debris Guard :: BMP Type: Catch Basin Insert (Pretreatment Technology). Pollutants Addressed: Debris- sinking; Debris - floatables ] Product of Kristar Enterprises, Inc.
27
TSS, Floatables
not specified
Grate Inlet Skimmer Box :: BMP Type: Catch Basin Insert (Pretreatment Technology). Pollutants Addressed: Total Keldhal Nitrogen; Total suspended solids; Debris - floatables; Total Phosphorus ] Product of Suntree Technologies Inc.
28
TSS
n/a
Cultec Stormfilter :: BMP Type: Screen separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids ] Product of Cultec
29
TSS, O/G
Oil and Sediment Model # 9217
UltraDrainguard® :: BMP Type: Catch Basin Insert (Pretreatment Technology). Pollutants Addressed: Oil and grease; Total suspended solids ] Product of UltraTech International
30
TSS, O/G, Floatables, SSC, DS
StormWater Filtration System(s)
ESI StormWater Filtration System™ :: BMP Type: Catch Basin Insert (Pretreatment Technology). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Total solids; Debris - floatables; Zinc; Lead; Chromium; Cadmium; Hydrocarbons; Organic contaminants; Total Phosphorus; Suspended sediment concentration; Total dissolved solids; Oil and grease; Debris- sinking; Copper; Iron; Mercury; Ammonium ] Product of EcoSense International
31
TN, NO3, Zn, Cu, Pb
bio-infiltration retrofit
Bio-Infiltration Traffic Island - Villanova :: BMP Type: Infiltration Basin (Infiltration). Pollutants Addressed: Zinc; Copper; Lead; Chromium; Nitrate; Total nitrogen; Total Phosphorus ] Product of LID - Non-proprietary
32
TSS, TP, Color, TS
Integrated LID
LID Development, Cross Plains Wisconsin :: BMP Type: Infiltration Basin (Infiltration). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Total solids; Total Phosphorus; Color ] Product of LID - Non-proprietary
33
TN, TKN, TP, NO3, NH4+
Rain Gardens
Rain Garden Bioretention LID - Haddam Connecticut :: BMP Type: Vegetative Filter Strips/Buffers (Filtration - Biofilter). Pollutants Addressed: Nitrate; Ammonium; Total Keldhal Nitrogen; Total nitrogen; Total Phosphorus ] Product of LID - Non-proprietary
34
TSS, TKN, TP, NO3, FC
Integrated LID
Jordan Cove Watershed Project :: BMP Type: Vegetative Filter Strips/Buffers (Filtration - Biofilter). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Zinc; Copper; Lead; Fecal coliform; Nitrate; Total Keldhal Nitrogen; Total Phosphorus; Temperature ] Product of LID - proprietary and non-proprietary components
35
TSS, TN, TP, NO3, Zn
Asphalt, cement, permeable pavement, grass swales
Low Impact Parking Lot Design at Florida Aquarium :: BMP Type: Porous Pavement (Infiltration). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Zinc; Copper; Lead; Iron; Nitrate; Total nitrogen; Total Phosphorus ] Product of LID - Non-proprietary
36
TSS, O/G
KW-C-550 Cylindrical Style
Kleerwater Oil Water Separator :: BMP Type: Oil/sediment separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Oil and grease ] Product of Modern Welding Company
37
TSS, TN, TKN, TP, NO3
Conventional and modified
Bioretention Cell - shopping center and mall - Greensboro & Chapel Hill North Carolina :: BMP Type: Vegetative Filter Strips/Buffers (Filtration - Biofilter). Pollutants Addressed: Zinc; Total suspended solids; Copper; Lead; Iron; Nitrate; Total Keldhal Nitrogen; Total nitrogen; Total Phosphorus ] Product of LID - Non-proprietary
38
TSS, Zn
swales with and without pretreatment
Grass Swales with and without pretreatment :: BMP Type: Grass Swale (Filtration - Biofilter). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Zinc ] Product of LID - Non-proprietary
39
TSS, Zn, Cu, Pb
porous pavement overlay
Porous Pavement Overlay :: BMP Type: Porous Pavement (Infiltration). Pollutants Addressed: Copper; Lead; Total Keldhal Nitrogen; Total suspended solids; Zinc ] Product of LID - proprietary and non-proprietary components
40
TSS, TKN, NH4+, EC, TN
HMBC
Bioretention Cell - Parking Lot NC :: BMP Type: Vegetative Filter Strips/Buffers (Filtration - Biofilter). Pollutants Addressed: Zinc; Fecal coliform; Total nitrogen; Copper; Lead; E. coli; Ammonium; Total Keldhal Nitrogen; Total suspended solids ] Product of LID - proprietary and non-proprietary components
41
TSS, TP, NO3, NH4+, O/G
110cm
Bioretention Column :: BMP Type: Vegetative Filter Strips/Buffers (Filtration - Biofilter). Pollutants Addressed: Total Phosphorus; Total suspended solids; Oil and grease; Lead; Nitrate; Ammonium ] Product of LID - proprietary and non-proprietary components
42
TSS, TS
Integrated LID
St.Francis residential subdivision - Brewery Creek WI :: BMP Type: Vegetative Filter Strips/Buffers (Filtration - Biofilter). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Total solids ] Product of LID - proprietary and non-proprietary components
43
O/G
test bed 610x610x780mm
permeable pavement - concrete, gravel, geotextile :: BMP Type: Porous Pavement (Infiltration). Pollutants Addressed: Oil and grease ] Product of LID - proprietary and non-proprietary components
44
TSS, TP, O/G, Zn
SV68
Stormvault :: BMP Type: Oil/sediment separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Oil and grease; Zinc; Total Phosphorus ] Product of Contech Stormwater Solutions, Inc.
45
TSS, TP, O/G
High School, Charlottesville VA
Bioretention cell :: BMP Type: Vegetative Filter Strips/Buffers (Filtration - Biofilter). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Oil and grease; Total Phosphorus ] Product of LID - Non-proprietary
46
TSS, TP, O/G
High School, Charlottesville VA
Bioretention Cell HS Parking Lot Charlottesville, VA :: BMP Type: Vegetative Filter Strips/Buffers (Filtration - Biofilter). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Oil and grease; Total Phosphorus ] Product of LID - Non-proprietary
47
TSS, TKN, TP, Cu
standard 6x6 unit
Filterra Bioretention Filtration System :: BMP Type: Vegetative Filter Strips/Buffers (Filtration - Biofilter). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Copper; Total Keldhal Nitrogen; Total Phosphorus ] Product of Filterra Bioretention Systems
48
TSS
Small scale single cartridge
Jellyfish :: BMP Type: Synthetic Filter (Filtration - Media filter). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids ] Product of Imbrium Systems Corporation
49
TSS, TN, TP, Zn, Pb
Porous pavement
Porous Pavement - parking lot Walden Pond :: BMP Type: Porous Pavement (Infiltration). Pollutants Addressed: Zinc; Total suspended solids; Lead; Total nitrogen; Total Phosphorus ] Product of LID - Non-proprietary
50
TSS, TP, SSC, Zn, TPH
SC-740
StormTech Isolator Row :: BMP Type: Synthetic Filter (Filtration - Media filter). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids; Zinc; Hydrocarbons; Total Phosphorus ] Product of StormTech LLC
51
SSC
HG 6
Hydroworks HG (Hydroguard) Separator :: BMP Type: Swirl or vortex separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids; Debris- sinking; Oil and grease; Debris - floatables; Hydrocarbons ] Product of Hydroworks LLC
52
TSS, TP, Odor, SSC
BayFilter Cartridge
BayFilter System :: BMP Type: Inorganic Filter (Filtration - Media filter). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids; Oil and grease; Debris - floatables; Debris- sinking; Zinc; Copper; Total Phosphorus; Odor ] Product of Baysaver
53
TSS, TP, SSC
1K
BaySaver Separation System :: BMP Type: Oil/sediment separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids; Oil and grease; Debris - floatables; Debris- sinking; Total Phosphorus ] Product of Baysaver
54
SSC
Various (AS-2 to AS-12)
Aqua-Swirl Concentrator :: BMP Type: Swirl or vortex separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration ] Product of AquaShield
55
TSS, SSC
AF - 3.2
AquaFilter Stormwater Filtration System :: BMP Type: Inorganic Filter (Filtration - Media filter). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids ] Product of AquaShield
56
TSS
V2B1
V2B1 :: BMP Type: Swirl or vortex separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Oil and grease; Debris - floatables; Debris- sinking; Total Phosphorus ] Product of Environment 21, LLC
57
SSC
STC450i
Stormceptor 450i :: BMP Type: Oil/sediment separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids; Oil and grease ] Product of Imbrium Systems Corporation
58
TSS
HS48
VortSentry HS :: BMP Type: Swirl or vortex separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration; Oil and grease; Zinc; Lead; Debris - floatables; Debris- sinking; Copper; Hydrocarbons; Total suspended solids ] Product of Contech Stormwater Solutions, Inc.
59
SSC
Model No. 3-6-72
Nutrient Separating Baffle Box :: BMP Type: Screen separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration ] Product of Suntree Technologies Inc.
60
TP, SSC
1 mm to 5 mm gradation
SorbtiveMEDIA :: BMP Type: Inorganic Filter (Filtration - Media filter). Pollutants Addressed: Copper; Mercury; Organic contaminants; Cadmium; Ammonium; Hydrocarbons; Lead; Iron; Chromium; Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids; Zinc; Total Phosphorus; Biochemical oxygen demand ] Product of Imbrium Systems Corporation
61
N/A
standard
Safe Drain :: BMP Type: Catch Basin Insert (Pretreatment Technology). Pollutants Addressed: Organic contaminants; Total suspended solids; Oil and grease; Debris- sinking; Hydrocarbons ] Product of Safe Drain Inc.
62
TSS, NO3/NO2, Floatables, TS, SSC
1056
CrystalStream Water Quality Vault :: BMP Type: Hydrodynamic device - other (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids; Total solids; Debris - floatables; Debris- sinking; Nitrate-nitrite ] Product of CrystalStream Technologies
63
TSS, SSC
1
Up-Flo Filter :: BMP Type: Synthetic Filter (Filtration - Media filter). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids ] Product of Hydro International
64
TSS, TP, TN, FC, Zn
large regional wet detention ponds
Wet detention ponds High Point NC :: BMP Type: Infiltration Basin (Infiltration). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Zinc; Copper; Lead; Iron; Fecal coliform; Total nitrogen; Total Phosphorus ] Product of Non Proprietary
65
TSS, TN, TP, FC
Wet ponds
Wet Detention Pond :: BMP Type: Infiltration Basin (Infiltration). Pollutants Addressed: Fecal coliform; Total nitrogen; Total Phosphorus; Total suspended solids ] Product of Non Proprietary
66
SSC
PMSU20_20_5
CDS Inline Unit :: BMP Type: Swirl or vortex separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Oil and grease; Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids; Debris - floatables ] Product of Contech Stormwater Solutions, Inc.
67
SSC
2 chamber
Oil Grit Separator :: BMP Type: Oil/sediment separator (Sedimentation Unit). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration ] Product of Non Proprietary
68
SSC
Hooded
Deep Sump Catch Basin :: BMP Type: Catch Basin - hooded (Pretreatment Technology). Pollutants Addressed: Suspended sediment concentration ] Product of Non Proprietary
69
TSS, TN, TP, NO3/NO2
1
Vegetated Filter Strips - switchgrass, cool season grass, Iowa :: BMP Type: Vegetative Filter Strips/Buffers (Filtration - Biofilter). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids; Nitrate-nitrite; Total nitrogen; Total Phosphorus ] Product of Non Proprietary
70
TP, SSC
SF66
SorbtiveFILTER :: BMP Type: Inorganic Filter (Filtration - Media filter). Pollutants Addressed: Oil and grease; Chromium; Organic contaminants; Cadmium; Total Keldhal Nitrogen; Total nitrogen; Total Phosphorus; Temperature; Color; Mercury; Odor; Odor; Debris - floatables; Zinc; Copper; Suspended sediment concentration; Total suspended solids; Ammonium; Hydrocarbons; Lead; Iron ] Product of Imbrium Systems Corporation
71
TP
variable grass types
Vegetated Filter Strips Phosphorus Removal Ontario :: BMP Type: Vegetative Filter Strips/Buffers (Filtration - Biofilter). Pollutants Addressed: Total Phosphorus ] Product of Non Proprietary
72
TSS
Ryegrass
Vegetative Filter Strips - Sediment Removal - Ontario :: BMP Type: Vegetative Filter Strips/Buffers (Filtration - Biofilter). Pollutants Addressed: Total suspended solids ] Product of Non Proprietary


 

Return to the Home Page
© 2004 University of Massachusetts Amherst. Site Policies. This site is maintained by MaSTEP. Comments to: webmaster.